- 1927/1928 – “Wings” Alex – 8.0 Elliot – 8.1
- 1928/1929 – “The Broadway Melody” Alex – 6.5 Elliot – 6.4
- 1929/1930 – “All Quiet on the Western Front” Alex – 8.3 Elliot –8.8
- 1930/1931 – “Cimarron” Alex – 6.7 Elliot – 6.8
- 1931/1932 – “Grand Hotel” Alex – 6.9 Elliot – 7.2
- 1932/1933 – “Cavalcade” Alex – 7.0 Elliot – 7.0
- 1934 – “It Happened One Night” Alex – 9.0 Elliot – 9.0
- 1935 – “Mutiny on the Bounty” Alex – 7.5 Elliot – 6.8
- 1936 – “The Great Ziegfeld” Alex – 8.1 Elliot – 7.8
- 1937 – “The Life of Emile Zola” Alex – 8.0 Elliot – 8.1
- 1938 – “You Can’t Take It with You” Alex – 8.5 Elliot – 8.7
- 1939 – “Gone with the Wind” Alex – 8.5 Elliot – 9.2
- 1940 – “Rebecca” Alex – 8.5 Elliot – 8.3
- 1941 – “How Green Was My Valley” Alex – 7.3 Elliot – 7.5
- 1942 – “Mrs. Miniver” Alex – 7.9 Elliot – 7.9
- 1943 – “Casablanca” Alex – 9.5 Elliot – 10.0
- 1944 – “Going My Way” Alex – 7.4 Elliot – 7.6
- 1945 – “The Lost Weekend” Alex – 7.8 Elliot – 7.6
- 1946 – “The Best Years of Our Lives” Alex – 8.4 Elliot – 8.2
- 1947 – “Gentleman’s Agreement” Alex – 8.0 Elliot – 7.2
- 1948 – “Hamlet” Alex – 7.0 Elliot – 7.2
- 1949 – “All the Kings Men” Alex –7.5 Elliot – 7.5
- 1950 – “All About Eve” Alex – 8.0 Elliot – 8.5
- 1951 – “An American in Paris” Alex – 7.2 Elliot – 7.5
- 1952 – “The Greatest Show on Earth” Alex – 6.5 Elliot – 6.3
- 1953 – “From Here to Eternity” Alex – 8.3 Elliot – 8.6
- 1954 – “On the Waterfront” Alex – 8.7 Elliot – 8.8
- 1955 – “Marty”
- 1956 – “Around the World in 80 Days”
- 1957 – “The Bridge on the River Kwai”
- 1958 – “Gigi”
- 1959 – “Ben-Hur”
- 1960 – “The Apartment”
- 1961 – “West Side Story”
- 1962 – “Lawrence of Arabia”
- 1963 – “Tom Jones”
- 1964 – “My Fair Lady”
- 1965 – “The Sound of Music”
- 1966 – “A Man for All Seasons”
- 1967 – “In the Heat of the Night”
- 1968 – “Oliver!”
- 1969 – “Midnight Cowboy”
- 1970 – “Patton”
- 1971 – “The French Connection”
- 1972 – “The Godfather”
- 1973 – “The Sting”
- 1974 – “The Godfather Part II”
- 1975 – “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest”
- 1976 – “Rocky”
- 1977 – “Annie Hall”
- 1978 – “The Deer Hunter”
- 1979 – “Kramer vs. Kramer”
- 1980 – “Ordinary People”
- 1981 – “Chariots of Fire”
- 1982 – “Gandhi”
- 1983 – “Terms of Endearment”
- 1984 – “Amadeus”
- 1985 – “Out of Africa”
- 1986 – “Platoon”
- 1987 – “The Last Emperor”
- 1988 – “Rain Man”
- 1989 – “Driving Miss Daisy”
- 1990 – “Dances With Wolves”
- 1991 – “The Silence of the Lambs”
- 1992 – “Unforgiven”
- 1993 – “Schindler’s List”
- 1994 – “Forrest Gump”
- 1995 – “Braveheart”
- 1996 – “The English Patient”
- 1997 – “Titanic”
- 1998 – “Shakespeare in Love”
- 1999 – “American Beauty”
- 2000 – “Gladiator”
- 2001 – “A Beautiful Mind”
- 2002 – “Chicago”
- 2003 – “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King”
- 2004 – “Million Dollar Baby”
- 2005 – “Crash”
- 2006 – “The Departed”
- 2007 – “No Country for Old Men”
- 2008 – “Slumdog Millionaire”
- 2009 – “The Hurt Locker”
- 2010 – “The King’s Speech”
- 2011 – “The Artist”
- 2012 – “Argo”
- 2013 – “12 Years a Slave”
- 2014 – “Birdman”
- 2015 – “Spotlight”
- 2016 – “Moonlight”
- 2017 – “The Shape of Water”
- 2018 – “Green Book”
- 2019 – “Parasite”